Email Marketing for Etsy Sellers: How to Turn Shoppers into Subscribers (And Why You Need To)
This post contains affiliate links. This means I will earn a commission if you purchase through my link, at no extra cost to you!
So you’ve got an Etsy shop.
You’re making beautiful things, pouring your heart into packaging, crossing your fingers with every launch... but something’s missing.
Here’s the truth: if Etsy disappeared tomorrow, would you have a way to reach your customers?
If that question just made your stomach drop, keep reading—this one’s for you.
Because while Etsy is a great marketplace, it’s not your business HQ.
Your real power? It’s in your email list—and today, we’re going to talk about exactly how to turn your casual Etsy shoppers into loyal subscribers, superfans, and repeat customers.
Let’s get into it.
Why Etsy Alone Isn’t Enough
Here’s the deal: Etsy owns the platform.
They control the traffic. They control the algorithm. They even own the customer’s email—you don’t.
That means you’re playing by their rules. And if Etsy changes something (again), or your listings stop getting views, or your shop gets flagged for a random reason?
You’re stuck.
But when someone joins your email list, everything changes.
Now you control the relationship. You can keep in touch, share updates, announce new products, and build real trust—all without hoping Etsy plays nice.
The Gold Is in the Follow-Up
Most shoppers won’t buy the first time they see your product.
But if they land on your Etsy page, fall in love with your vibe, and then leave?
They’re gone—unless you’ve got a way to bring them back.
That’s what an email list does.
It gives you a second chance. A third. A fourth.
It turns one-time browsers into long-term buyers.
So how do you actually get those subscribers? Let’s break it down.
1. Offer a Juicy Freebie or Discount
Everyone loves a good deal. If you want someone to join your list, give them a reason.
Try this:
“Get 15% off your first order when you join my email list!”
“Snag a free printable art piece just for signing up!”
“Want early access to my next product launch? Join here.”
Keep it simple, clear, and on-brand.
Then use a tool like Flodesk to create a stunning opt-in form that doesn’t feel boring or corporate. (Seriously, it’s the most artist-friendly email platform out there—and you can grab 50% off Flodesk right here).
2. Add an Opt-In Link Everywhere
Make it ridiculously easy for people to join your list.
Here’s where to sprinkle your opt-in magic:
Your Etsy announcement banner
Your product descriptions
Your thank-you email after someone places an order
Your order packaging (print a cute card with a QR code or link!)
Your social media bio
People want to stay in touch—you just have to invite them.
3. Turn Every Customer Into a Subscriber
This one’s gold: include a sign-up link or incentive in your order packaging.
Example:
“Tear this open, smile at your new goodies, and then scan this QR code for a surprise discount on your next order!”
They already love what they bought—this is the perfect moment to deepen the relationship.
4. Send Emails People Actually Want to Read
Once they’re on your list, don’t just show up when you’re trying to sell something.
Show up like a real human with real passion for what you do.
Try emails like:
“A behind-the-scenes look at this week’s batch of mugs”
“My biggest shipping disaster (and what I learned from it)”
“What’s coming to the shop next month—subscribers get first dibs!”
Keep it personal. Keep it simple. Keep it consistent.
5. Use Flodesk to Keep It Gorgeous and Easy
Look—if you’re an artist, maker, or creative, you probably don’t want to mess with clunky tech platforms that look like spreadsheets.
That’s why I recommend Flodesk.
You can create gorgeous, on-brand emails in minutes. No code. No fuss. Just beautiful results and an interface that actually makes sense.
Bonus: they don’t charge you more as your list grows. It’s one flat fee—and you can get 50% off for a year using my affiliate link right here.
This Isn’t Just About Sales. It’s About Ownership.
Let’s get real for a second. Etsy is a tool. But your email list?
That’s your business backbone. It’s how you create a brand that lasts.
It’s your space. Your voice. Your community.
So stop depending on algorithms and start building something sustainable.
Your future self will thank you.
Don’t forget to snag your 50% off Flodesk deal if you’re ready to make your emails as beautiful as your products.
Your dream customers are waiting. Let’s invite them in.
